Peanut Butter, Jelly & Spreads (159)

Dalmatia Fig Orange Spread, 8.5 Ounce, $7.99

Dalmatia Fig Spread, 1.05 Ounce, $1.99

Each fig is inspected for quality. For nutritional information please see www.Figspread.com. Product of Croatia.

Dalmatia Organic Apricot Spread, 8.5 Ounce, $8.49

Dalmatia Organic Super Berry Spread, 8.5 Ounce, $7.49

Organic Super Berry Spread - a super day begins with a super morning and a super breakfast. Perfect mix of antioxidant superfoods — sweet blueberries, exotic goji berries, and deep purple aronia berries. Great for breakfast or any time of day!

Dalmatia Original Fig Spread, 8.5 Ounce, $7.99

Dalmatia® Fig Spread Original. This all natural, fruit-rich spread made of Adriatic figs is cooked in small batches to create a rich, intense, fruity flavor, with delicious fig chunks throughout. Our recipes are crafted using traditional cooking methods. We guarantee the purity of our raw ingredients. The perfect addition to any cheese plate - pairs with all cheese varieties from brie, to blue cheeses to aged cheddars. Blend with chopped almonds and plain Greek yogurt. Try with cream cheese on toast. www.figspread.com. www.atalantacorp.com.

Dalmatia Sour Cherry Spread, 8.5 Ounce, $8.49

Divina Fig Spread, 9 Ounce, $6.99

Divina Fig Spread, Orange, 9 Ounce, $6.99

Duerr's Marmalade, Coarse Cut, Seville Orange, 16 Ounce, $5.99

Duerr's Mint Sauce, 9.9 Ounce, $6.99

Earth Balance Coconut & Peanut Spread, Creamy, 16 Ounce, $8.99

Non GMO Verified

Felix Lingonberries, 10 Ounce, $10.79

Fromage Ami Mango Chutney for Cheese, 6 Ounce, $8.99

Warming winter spices are mingled with the sweet tropical flavors of fresh mangos and spicy ginger. Try this chutney paired with sharp white Cheddar or as a filling alongside fresh cream cheese in a warm croissant. With so many uses, this chutney is sure to become your new pairing obsession.

Fromage Ami Sour Cherry Spread for Cheese, 6 Ounce, $8.99

A perfect balance of sweet and sour. Made using a blend of tart and sweet summer cherries, this spread is an irresistible accompaniment to your favorite cheeses or desserts. Try it alongside hard, salty cheeses like Pecorino Romano, or as a topping on your next vanilla ice cream sundae.

Gales Lemon Curd, 14.5 Ounce, $7.99

Ginger People Organic Ginger Spread, 8.5 Ounce, $7.79

Expand your culinary coolness with this organic, sweet-hot, dreamy ingredient. A super versatile jammy paste made of organic baby ginger and pure cane sugar – yep, that’s it.

Girl Meets Dirt Orcas Pear with Bay Spoon Preserves, 7.75 Ounce, $16.29

At the height of ripeness these local delicacies (discovered growing wild on Orcas in the 1970s) cook beautifully into a rosy preserve, with notes of ginger from our fresh kitchen garden grown bay leaves.

Girl Meets Dirt Pear Balsamic Spoon Preserves, 7.75 Ounce, $16.99

Crafted with Bartlett pears from heirloom orchards and reduced down with organic aged balsamic vinegar into a balanced and nuanced pear jam. Founder Audra began making this preserve after discovering her neighbors 120+ year old Bartlett orchard and their gracious offer to lend the pears in exchange for jam.

Girl Meets Dirt Rhubarb Lavendar Spoon Preserves, 7.75 Ounce, $16.99

Deep within Orcas Island's bucolic Crow Valley, once planted as far as the eye could see in orchard fruit, lies JBS Farm's gorgeous patch of rhubarb from which this rhubarb jam is made. We've selected their deep red Valentine variety for this batch of fruit preserves – lightly infused with garden grown English culinary lavender buds. Supplemented with the best organic rhubarb from a hop and skip from the ferry landing in the fertile Skagit Valley, this rhubarb jam is the perfect balance of tart and sweet with just a touch of floral.

Girl Meets Dirt Tomato Jam Spoon Preserves, 7.75 Ounce, $16.99

This year’s batch includes beautiful ruby Amish paste tomatoes from Maple Rock Farm on Orcas, outdoor grown, sun-ripened and kissed by the ocean breezes in Crow Valley, and gorgeous heirlooms coddled by Mama Bird on San Juan. This past season we also brought in the lauded Dirty Girl Produce dry farmed Early Girls – and the combination is genius! We tease out the natural sweetness of these beauties with organic cane sugar, curls of organic lemon zest, and a pinch of San Juan Sea Salt.

Good Good Jelly, Apricot Jam, 12 Ounce, $8.99

Good Good Jelly, Chocolate Hazelnut, 12 Ounce, $8.49

Good Good Jelly, Forest Fruits, 12 Ounce, $7.79

Good Good Jelly, Grape Jelly, 12 Ounce, $7.79

Good Good Jelly, Raspberry Jam, 12 Ounce, $7.79

Good Good Jelly, Strawberry Jam, 12 Ounce, $7.79

Haleakala Creamery Caramel Goat Milk, 2 Ounce, $9.29

Haleakala Creamery Caramel Trio Box, 2 Ounce, $24.00

Haleakala Creamery Choc Caramel, 2 Ounce, $9.00

Haleakala Creamery Coconut Rum Caramel, 2 Ounce, $9.29