Peanut Butter, Jelly & Spreads (121)

Duerr's Marmalade, Coarse Cut, Seville Orange, 16 Ounce, $6.99

Duerr's Mint Sauce, 9.9 Ounce, $5.99

Earth Balance Coconut & Peanut Spread, Creamy, 16 Ounce, $7.59

Non GMO Verified

Felix Lingonberries, 10 Ounce, $8.49

Fromage Ami Mango Chutney for Cheese, 6 Ounce, $8.99

Warming winter spices are mingled with the sweet tropical flavors of fresh mangos and spicy ginger. Try this chutney paired with sharp white Cheddar or as a filling alongside fresh cream cheese in a warm croissant. With so many uses, this chutney is sure to become your new pairing obsession.

Ginger People Organic Ginger Spread, 8.5 Ounce, $7.49

Expand your culinary coolness with this organic, sweet-hot, dreamy ingredient. A super versatile jammy paste made of organic baby ginger and pure cane sugar – yep, that’s it.

Good Good Jelly, Chocolate Hazelnut, 12 Ounce, $9.99

Good Good Jelly, Forest Fruits, 12 Ounce, $8.99

Good Good Jelly, Grape Jelly, 12 Ounce, $8.99

Good Good Jelly, Raspberry Jam, 12 Ounce, $8.99

Haleakala Creamery Caramel Goat Milk, 2 Ounce, $8.99

Haleakala Creamery Caramel Trio Box, 6 Ounce, $24.00

Haleakala Creamery Coconut Rum Caramel, 2 Ounce, $8.99

Haleakala Creamery Hawaiian Vanilla Caramel, 2 Ounce, $8.99

Haleakala Creamery Sea Salt Caramel, 2 Ounce, $8.99

Hawaiian Sun Guava Jam, 10 Ounce, $3.50

Island favorite. Since 1952. Made in Hawaii (USA).

Hawaiian Sun Guava Jelly, 10 Ounce, $3.50

Island favorite. Since 1952. Made in Hawaii (USA).

Hawaiian Sun Jam, Pineapple, 10 Ounce, $3.50

Island favorite. Since 1952. Made in Hawaii (USA).

Hawaiian Sun Lilikoi Passion Fruit Jelly, 10 Ounce, $3.50

Island favorite. Since 1952. Made in Hawaii (USA).

Hawaiian Sun Strawberry Guava Jam, 10 Ounce, $3.50

Island favorite. Since 1952. Made in Hawaii (USA).

Jenkins Jellies Guava Brava Pepper Jelly, 5 Ounce, $6.69

Jenkins Jellies Hell Fire Pepper Jelly, 5 Ounce, $6.69

Hell Fire is the original blend of seven fresh peppers, mingling savory & sweet with irresistible heat to elevate just about any cocktail, appetizer, main dish or desert. Each jar is a secret ingredient for the creative home chef. A stunning accompaniment to cheese boards, grazing tables & charcuterie platters; as well as BBQing, dipping sauces & marinades. Create craft classic cocktails with a twist, fire up standard condiments or add depth to a gooey grilled cheese.

Jenkins Jellies Passion Fire Pepper Jelly, 5 Ounce, $6.69

Jif Extra Crunchy Peanut Butter, 16 Ounce, $4.79

<ul> <li>190 Calories per 2 TBSP</li> <li>7g Protein per serving</li> <li>Non GMO</li> </ul>

Jif Peanut Butter & Chocolate Flavored Spread, 15 Ounce, $5.69

Jif Peanut Butter No Added Sugar, 15.5 Ounce, $4.69

From a brand that has been trusted for generations, our creamy peanut butter spread is made with three ingredients — and no added sugar — for a delicious peanut butter flavor you’ll love. One bite of Jif No Added Sugar* Creamy Peanut Butter Spread and you’ll be reminded of your very best childhood memories. Make sandwiches to fuel a long afternoon of school and practice, bake delicious cookies while making memories with family, and of course, take delicious bites right from the spoon with this smooth-textured peanut butter spread - no stirring required. And with a jar of Jif No Added Sugar Creamy Peanut Butter Spread, you’ll always have this classic peanut butter treat on hand!

Jif Peanut Butter Squeezable Pouch, 13 Ounce, $5.49

JIF Peanut Butter, Creamy, 16 Ounce, $4.79

<ul> <li>Non GMO</li> <li>Gluten Free</li> <li>2 Tablespoons per serving</li> <li>190 Calories and 7 g Protein per serving</li> </ul>

Joyva Sesame Tahini, 15 Ounce, $13.19

Joyva roasted sesame tahini is an all-natural creamy puree of sesame seeds that has a light nut-like flavor. Each 15 Oz container provides 15 servings of about 2 TBSP. Each. Each serving has 200 calories, 5 grams of protein and 1 gram of dietary fiber. Our tahini contains no additives or emulsifiers. See nutrition panel for allergens.

Justin's Almond Butter, Honey, 1 Ounce, $1.59